How did Afghanistan’s security forces lose the war?

How did Afghanistan’s safety forces lose the conflict?

Building Afghanistan’s nationwide safety forces was one of the vital formidable and costly points of 20 years of US-led conflict.

It resulted in failure.

The USA spent billions of {dollars} coaching and equipping police, troopers and particular forces. Regardless of years of warnings from US and Afghan officers, successive US administrations pledged that the Afghan navy was able to defending the nation. President Joe Biden mentioned it was “as well-equipped as any military on the earth” only a month earlier than its collapse.

At this time, not a single unit of the nation’s safety forces stays intact.

A complicated Taliban marketing campaign geared toward securing give up offers lay on the coronary heart of the Afghan navy’s collapse, however layers of corruption, waste and logistical failures left the nation’s safety forces so underequipped and with such battered morale that it enabled the militants’ success.

Interviews with greater than a dozen members of the Afghan particular forces, military and police in three provinces from Could to July illustrate that the collapse of safety forces was not abrupt. As a substitute, it was a sluggish, painful breakdown that started months earlier than the autumn of Kabul.

Early Could, Kabul

Demise stalked Afghanistan’s safety forces within the spring. Because the tempo of the US withdrawal elevated, and the Taliban continued its relentless sweep via rural Afghanistan, casualties amongst authorities fighters surged.

The final time Niazi’s household spoke to him was throughout a hurried cellphone name. The Afghan nationwide military soldier, who goes by one title, was stationed at a distant outpost in Baghlan province.

“He advised me he was wonderful,” mentioned his mom, Bas Bigum. However she might sense from his voice that he feared for his life. “We all know what occurs when the Taliban surrounds a base.”



Because the conflict intensified, lots of Afghanistan’s police on the entrance line had been getting into their sixth month with out pay

Niazi’s Afghan military unit was attacked inside its personal base after being surrounded by Taliban fighters. The unit’s commander fled.

Niazi was injured within the subsequent battle, and he later died of his wounds at a Kabul hospital.

The household by no means obtained formal condolences from the nation’s navy, nor did the Defence Ministry assist cowl the funeral prices.

Could, Kandahar province

Because the conflict intensified, lots of Afghanistan’s police on the entrance line had been getting into their sixth month with out pay, a widespread drawback that took a toll on authorities forces’ morale and made them weak to Taliban gives.

At a small outpost south of Kandahar metropolis, Noor Ahmad Zhargi was on guard responsibility. The Eid vacation marking the tip of Ramadan was approaching and even when he was granted depart, he mentioned he wouldn’t go dwelling.

“I might be too ashamed to have a look at my kids with empty arms,” he mentioned.

When he joined Afghanistan’s police pressure, all he was given was a gun – no coaching or documentation.

A funeral for a policeman killed on the entrance line

(Lorenzo Tugnoli/The Washington Put up)

“Subsequent month, if the federal government doesn’t pay me, possibly I ought to simply promote this to the Taliban,” he mentioned, holding the rifle. He mentioned he had heard the Taliban was paying about $2,000 (£1,500) for Afghan authorities weapons like his, a value a lot larger than the market price. He insisted he would by no means be part of the Taliban however dodged a query about whether or not he would give up.

Two months later, Zhargi’s publish had fallen to the Taliban, together with almost each different district in Kandahar, apart from the provincial capital. Different police within the metropolis mentioned they heard everybody on the publish had surrendered, and plenty of had been taken by the militants. Nobody knew in the event that they had been nonetheless being held as prisoners or had been executed.

Afghanistan’s most extremely skilled fighters had been assigned to defensive operations because the Taliban pushed nearer to provincial capitals and as US air assist disappeared. Elite fighters had been tasked with working harmful resupply missions that made them inclined to Taliban ambushes.

“This isn’t what we had been skilled to do,” mentioned Lt Abdul Hamid Barakzai of the Afghan commandos, referring to the drives between outposts the place Taliban fighters usually positioned snipers or roadside bombs. He mentioned the commandos got the duty as a result of they had been one of many few items with closely armoured autos.

Policemen injured on the entrance traces recuperate in Kandahar’s most important hospital on 31 July, simply two weeks earlier than the Taliban took management of the nation

(Lorenzo Tugnoli/The Washington Put up)

As one workforce arrived at a small maze-like base to drop off bread and vitality drinks, a Taliban sniper spherical ricocheted off the aspect of a closely armoured automobile, sending shrapnel into the abdomen of one of many troopers. He rapidly wrapped a shawl across the wound and brushed it off. “They shoot at us like this each day,” one of many different males mentioned.

The Taliban snipers had been additionally proving lethal. At one base, the guard on responsibility stepped outdoors to take a cellphone name and was shot and killed immediately. At one other, a policeman getting back from patrol was shot via the guts.

Safety forces had been additionally being focused inside Kandahar metropolis.

Shakila’s husband – a policeman – started receiving threatening letters from the Taliban two months earlier than he was gunned down within the metropolis’s central bazaar.

“I used to be at all times begging him, you don’t must proceed this job, it’s too harmful,” she mentioned. However her husband, Mohammad Sadiq Nabizada, couldn’t discover different work.

July, Kunduz province

By July, the Afghan authorities had misplaced management of huge swaths of the nation and was counting on elite items – one of the best skilled, outfitted and customarily most motivated – to steer the battle.

However with out US oversight, the troops had been being mismanaged and overworked.

Afghan particular forces fighters had been skilled to hold out focused evening operations to arrest suspects or regain territory. However within the closing months of the conflict, particular forces in Kunduz and elsewhere had been battling on the entrance traces

(Lorenzo Tugnoli/The Washington Put up)

“We knew learn how to defeat the Taliban, however the management on the prime didn’t pay attention,” mentioned a captain in one among Afghanistan’s most elite items. He spoke on the situation of anonymity as a result of he was not authorised to talk to the press.

As the USA withdrew its forces, Afghanistan particular operators had been largely moved beneath the command of the Defence Ministry. The shift robbed the items of a level of independence that had insulated them from the corruption that handicapped different branches of the nation’s safety forces, the captain mentioned.

He mentioned he introduced his supervisor with a number of plans to reorganise the nation’s safety forces and to push again the militants’ advances. However every time he was rebuffed.

“As a substitute, we had been despatched to conduct clearing operations with no assist,” he mentioned. “That isn’t the way you win a conflict. We had been letting the enemy select the battle house; we must always have been taking the battle to them.”

The captain admitted that the lads in his unit had been additionally struggling to function with out US coordination and air assist. There was by no means an effort to wean the items off American backing, and so many abruptly discovered themselves with out instruments that they had relied on for years to conduct even easy operations, the captain mentioned. Two different Afghan particular forces officers confirmed his account.

As one particular forces unit in Kunduz ready to go on depart, its commander confided that he feared lots of his males wouldn’t return to their subsequent rotation.

Preventing raged within the areas round Kandahar metropolis for months earlier than the town fell in mid-August

(Lorenzo Tugnoli/The Washington Put up)

“My guys are drained,” he mentioned of the four-month rotation of near-daily front-line fight. He additionally spoke on the situation of anonymity as a result of he was not authorised to talk to the press. “And we’re uninterested in this nonsense.” Defence Ministry forms was additionally starting to cripple operations. Nicely-planned missions can be modified or cancelled on the final minute and assist forces wouldn’t seem or would disregard orders.

“If I take 100 of my guys alone, we are able to defend my village from the Taliban,” the captain mentioned, “however with the Defence Ministry, we are able to’t do something.” Weeks earlier than Kabul fell, he mentioned he was contemplating leaving his place to start out up a militia in his hometown.

“There are many males who wish to battle,” he mentioned. “It’s the management that’s holding them again.”

Each the particular forces commander in Kunduz and the captain fled Afghanistan on US evacuation flights with their households. The captain mentioned he nonetheless hopes to return to withstand the Taliban.

July, Kandahar

By late July, the Taliban was closing in on almost all of the nation’s provincial capitals. Afghan safety forces that hadn’t been killed by the Taliban had abandoned or repeatedly fled, steadily retreating from distant outposts into metropolis centres.

Those that remained on the nation’s entrance traces had been a number of the least succesful.

Relations attend a funeral in Could for Niazi, an Afghan nationwide military soldier who was killed after his outpost was surrounded by the Taliban

(Lorenzo Tugnoli/The Washington Put up)

“The Taliban are all over the place now, even inside the town,” mentioned Obidullah Bilal, a wounded policeman in Kandahar’s central hospital. He was driving an unarmored police truck via japanese Kandahar to resupply a checkpoint when he was caught by a Taliban ambush.

“It’s due to our management that we’re on this place,” he mentioned, referring to the large territorial losses the federal government had suffered in a matter of weeks. “Our leaders promote our checkpoints. They’ve already offered our blood.”

One police commander mentioned the one males from his unit prepared to carry positions in opposition to the Taliban had been drug addicts.

“It retains them awake,” mentioned Mirza Wali, a police commander attending the funeral for one among his males, Nik Mohammad, who had been killed by the Taliban ambush the evening earlier than.

Mohammad was estranged from his household due to his meth dependancy, however his sister and mom, Taj Bibi, attended the funeral. They each sat within the shade of a truck just a few metres from the place Mohammad’s coffin was being coated with earth.

“The addicts are the one ones who can stand being on the entrance line,” Wali mentioned. “In the event that they weren’t utilizing medicine, they might go loopy.”

© The Washington Put up

Posted in world

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *